Call Us

  • Village Plaza: 607-796-2677
  • 2898 Westinghouse Rd
    Horseheads NY 14845
  • Arnot Mall: 607-739-4641
  • 3300 Chambers Rd.
    Horseheads, NY 14845
  • Big Flats: 607-562-7000
  • 84 Canal St #1
    Big Flats, NY 14814
Picnic Pizza

Making fresh, hand-tossed, New
York Style pizza for over 50 years.

BBQ Chicken Wings

Hand Tossed New York Style Pizzas – Serving Arnot Mall in Horseheads, NY

When you want to serve your family a meal, full of love and classic Italian flavor, come to Picnic Pizza.

Each of our hand tossed New York Style pizzas are made fresh each day. All our vegetables are fresh, and our sub sauce and meatballs are made in house.

At Picnic Pizza,

At Picnic Pizza, you’ll get a flavorful, delicious meal at a budget the whole family will love. Our menu offers a variety of wonderful Italian dishes, including: • Subs, • Strombolis, • Calzones, • Wings, • Salads, • New York Style Pizza
Pizza and Veggies
  • All items on menu are subject to N.Y.S sales tax
  • Menu items subject to change!
  • Prices subject to change according to market conditions.
  • Prices effective April 15, 2018
Buon Appetito
Strombolis & Calzones
*When ordering please allow 12-15 minutes baking time for these speciality calzones and strombolis
Homemade fresh dough Neopolitan style (thin)
White Garlic Sheet Pizza
By the slice
Fancy Pizzas
Available in 16″ medium (8 cuts) and 18″ large (12 cuts)
All our submarines and hoagies come with a side order of french fries. (In restaurant only)
Charge for sharing $1.00
We do our part to keep the environment clean by recycling our glass, metal cans and the cooking oil used in our restaurants. We also use recyclable packaging.

Contact Info


Village Plaza Westinghouse Rd
Horseheads NY 14845

Arnot Mall
Horseheads NY 14845

Miniers Plaza Canal St
Big Flats NY 14814

We Accept:
Visa, MasterCard, Discover, AmEx and Cash

Contact Us

5 + 9 =



Village Plaza, Westinghouse Rd.
Monday - Thursday: 11am - 10pm
Friday - Saturday: 11am - 11pm
Sunday: 11am - 10pm

Arnot Mall, Horseheads NY
Monday - Saturday: 10am - 9:30pm
Sunday: 12am - 5pm

Miniers Plaza Canal St, Big Flats NY
Monday - Thursday: 11am - 10pm
Friday - Saturday: 11am - 11pm
Sunday: 11am - 10pm