Italian Food in Horseheads, NY

At Picnic Pizza, we believe that food and family go hand in hand. That’s why we’re proud to offer the fresh food that has made you a part of our family for over 50 years.

We put love and care into each dish we prepare. We make our hand tossed and hand stretched dough fresh each day. We use fresh veggies in all our dishes, and our sub sauce and meatballs are made in-house.

We’re proud to say that at Picnic Pizza, we make everything with love. We wouldn’t have it any other way.

About Picnic Pizza

Picnic Pizza has two locations in Horseheads and one location in Big Flats. We can deliver to any address that’s within 5 miles of two of our convenient Chemung County locations (Village Plaza & Big Flats).

We specialize in a wide range of delicious Italian dishes, including:

New York Style Pizza
Wings

Subs
Strombolis

Calzones
Salads
And More

New York Style Pizza
Wings
Subs
Strombolis
Calzones
Salads
And More

What Do Our Customers Have to Say?

“Love the pizza and the atmosphere and the staff! It’s real pizza, not that cardboard stuff from a chain restaurant and it’s all handmade, seriously, you can watch them make the dough and all!” – Colin J. from Yelp

“This is the pizzeria I frequent most often when I need a pizza fix. New York style at its best. The crust is crispy, the sauce and oregano make for a great tasting pie at a very reasonable price.” – Eric L. from TripAdvisor

“While their New York style pie is pretty good, for me the real stars of Picnic Pizza are their squares. Their sheet pizza is very good IMO and their Sicilian is also good if you like a thick, spongy crust. Their tomato sauce is nice and generous toppings. Their chicken wings are some of the best in the area” – Clinton C. from Yelp

“For the first time I’ve had pizza that wasn’t too greasy, not undercooked, not scalding hot and had crust of perfect thickness! Probably the best Sicilian pizza I’ve had as a Western New Yorker.” – Nimish G. from Google Reviews

Contact Info

Phone:
607-796-2677

Locations:
Village Plaza Westinghouse Rd
Horseheads NY 14845

Arnot Mall
Horseheads NY 14845

Miniers Plaza Canal St
Big Flats NY 14814

We Accept:
Visa, MasterCard, Discover, AmEx and Cash

Contact Us

Hours

Village Plaza, Westinghouse Rd.
Monday - Thursday: 11am - 10pm
Friday - Saturday: 11am - 11pm
Sunday: 11am - 10pm

Arnot Mall, Horseheads NY
Monday - Saturday: 10am - 9:30pm
Sunday: 12am - 5pm

Miniers Plaza Canal St, Big Flats NY
Monday - Thursday: 11am - 10pm
Friday - Saturday: 11am - 11pm
Sunday: 11am - 10pm